VIRALIRL
IGINEMAIL
Marketplace3 min read

Amazon, Flipkart, Myntra or Nykaa: which marketplace should a D2C brand launch on first?

A practical way for Indian D2C brands to choose their first marketplace — by category, price point, operations and margin — and when to add the second one.

By Viral IRL

"Which marketplace should we start with?" is one of the first questions founders ask us. The honest answer is that there is no single best marketplace — but there is a clear order of questions that gets most brands to the right first choice quickly.

Start with category fit

Each major Indian marketplace has a centre of gravity. Customers go to it with a particular kind of purchase in mind, and the platform's discovery, filters and merchandising are built around that.

  • Myntra — fashion, footwear, accessories and lifestyle, with a growing beauty range. Strong for brands where presentation and fit information matter.
  • Ajio — fashion and lifestyle, with a similar brand-led, fashion-first approach.
  • Nykaa — beauty and personal care first, plus Nykaa Fashion for apparel and accessories.
  • Amazon — a broad marketplace across almost every category, with mature sponsored ads and strong brand tools such as A+ content and brand registry.
  • Flipkart — another broad marketplace, with a large audience across electronics, fashion, home and more, and big seasonal sale events.
  • Meesho — built around value and low prices, reaching many price-sensitive shoppers. A strong channel if your products and margins work at those price points, and a difficult one if they do not.

If your category is fashion, beauty or lifestyle, the specialist platforms usually deserve a serious look first. For most other categories, Amazon or Flipkart is the natural starting point.

Then check the economics for your category

Commission, fixed fees, shipping, payment collection and returns all vary by marketplace and by category. Before committing, build a simple per-order model for your top three SKUs on each shortlisted platform:

  1. Selling price, after the discount you expect to run.
  2. Minus the marketplace's commission and fees for your category.
  3. Minus shipping and packaging.
  4. Minus expected returns and refused deliveries.
  5. Minus product cost.

What is left is your contribution per order before advertising. If it is thin on one platform, ads there will be hard to make profitable — see our note on break-even ROAS.

Then check whether you can meet the operational standard

Marketplaces reward sellers who ship on time, cancel rarely and keep listings accurate, and penalise those who do not. Be honest about:

  • Fulfilment — will you use the marketplace's fulfilment network, ship yourself, or use a third-party warehouse?
  • Stock depth — can you keep your top SKUs in stock? A stock-out costs ranking as well as sales.
  • Content — do you have marketplace-ready images, size charts and product information in the formats each platform requires?
  • People — who checks the account every day?

Our default recommendation

  1. Pick one marketplace where your category fits and the per-order economics work.
  2. Launch it properly: complete listings, compliant images, enough stock for at least the first 8–12 weeks of demand, and a small, tightly controlled sponsored-ads budget.
  3. Run a weekly review of listings, stock, pricing, ads and returns — the five revenue leaks are a good checklist.
  4. Add the second marketplace once the first runs predictably, reusing the catalog content and learnings you have already built.

Brands that launch on five platforms at once with a small catalog usually end up with five half-maintained accounts. Brands that go one at a time build a system they can repeat.

Don't forget your own store

Marketplaces bring demand, but the customer relationship stays with the platform. Your own Shopify or WordPress store is where you keep customer data, margin and brand control. Most of the brands we run use marketplaces for reach and their own store for repeat customers and higher-margin sales.

Not sure which platform fits your category? Send us a brief with what you sell and your price range, and we will tell you where we would start.

Frequently asked questions

Is Amazon or Flipkart better for a new D2C brand in India?
Both are broad marketplaces with large audiences. The better first choice depends on your category, where your customers shop, and your fees and logistics for that category. Many brands start on whichever platform their category performs best on, then add the other within months.
Should a fashion brand start on Myntra or Amazon?
Fashion and lifestyle brands often start on Myntra because it is built around fashion discovery and brand presentation, with Ajio as a similar fashion-first option. Amazon and Flipkart add broad reach and are usually the next step.
Is Nykaa only for beauty brands?
Nykaa is best known for beauty and personal care, where it is a natural first marketplace for many brands. It also runs Nykaa Fashion for apparel and accessories.
How many marketplaces should a D2C brand sell on?
Start with one and run it well — complete listings, stable stock, controlled ads and healthy account metrics. Add a second once the first is operating predictably. Expanding too early multiplies operational work faster than it multiplies sales.

Keep reading